Chapter 4 - The Garage Floor

I did not go home that morning.
Matthew insisted my apartment was no longer safe.
I refused to get into his car.
So he followed mine from a distance while Officer Hayes—who I finally called and told only part of the truth—met me at a twenty-four-hour pharmacy across town.
The sky was gray with early morning rain. Chicago looked washed out and tired, like the city had not slept in years.
Officer Hayes stood beside my car, hands on his belt.
“You want to explain why a man like Matthew Valentine knows your real name?” he asked.
“No.”
“That wasn’t an option.”
I looked at him.
For weeks, he had been just another tired cop who drank black coffee and tipped too much. He never flirted. Never asked why I worked nights. Never treated me like I owed him a smile.
But trust was dangerous.
“I was in witness protection,” I said.
His expression changed.
“From what?”
“My father was Detective Samuel Voss.”
Officer Hayes went very still.
“I know that name.”
“Most cops do.”
“He was killed working a syndicate case.”
“Yes.”
“And Matthew Valentine?”
“I don’t know what he wants. He says my father left evidence behind.”
Hayes looked past me toward the black sedan parked across the street. Matthew sat in the back seat, speaking quietly into a phone.
“You understand why that worries me.”
“It worries me too.”
Hayes lowered his voice.
“Then don’t go anywhere with him.”
I almost said I wouldn’t.
But another message appeared on my phone.
This time it included a photo.
My apartment building.
Taken from across the street.
Beneath it, one sentence.
NICE PLACE. THREE DEAD BOLTS WON’T HELP.
My body went cold.
Hayes read it over my shoulder.
“Okay,” he said. “You’re not going home.”
“What am I supposed to do?”
He looked at Matthew’s sedan again.
Then at me.
“Maybe we find out whether Valentine is lying.”
Matthew agreed to meet us at a neutral location.
A church basement in Bridgeport that had been closed for renovations. Hayes called in one person he trusted: Detective Mara Chen, a veteran investigator from the Organized Crime Division.
When Matthew arrived alone, Detective Chen placed a handgun on the folding table between them.
“Phone,” she said.
Matthew handed it over.
“Keys.”
He handed those over too.
“Any weapons?”
“A knife.”
“Where?”
“Ankle holster.”
Hayes blinked.
Matthew smiled.
“You asked.”
They searched him, then let him sit.
Detective Chen pulled up a file.
“Matthew Valentine. Former lieutenant for Vale Street. Three arrests, no convictions. Two suspected homicide connections. Owner of four legitimate businesses and one nightclub that somehow stays profitable despite serving terrible drinks.”
Matthew leaned back in his chair.
“Your research is flattering.”
“Why are you looking for Lena Voss?”
“Because her father hid the Vale Street ledger.”
“And you want it for yourself?”
“I want it away from Victor Raines.”
The name changed the room.
Detective Chen’s face hardened.
“Victor Raines is dead.”
Matthew’s eyes did not move.
“No,” he said. “Victor Raines disappeared.”
“He was shot in 2008.”
“A body was never recovered.”
Hayes looked at Chen. “Is that true?”
She did not answer.
Matthew continued.
“Raines built Vale Street. He paid cops, city officials, judges, union bosses. He made people disappear. When Detective Voss began collecting evidence, Raines ordered him killed.”
“And your brother?” I asked.
Matthew’s expression became sharp.
“My brother was supposed to testify.”
The room went quiet.
“His name was Daniel Valentine,” Matthew said. “He was nineteen. He drove deliveries for the syndicate, got scared, tried to walk away. Raines had him killed and made it look like a robbery.”
I looked at him differently.
Not with trust.
But with understanding.
“You joined them after that?” Hayes asked.
“I joined them to survive,” Matthew replied. “Then I built enough power that Raines could not erase me too.”
Detective Chen slid a photo across the table.
It showed my childhood home.
The old garage.
The workbench.
“What do you remember?” she asked.
I closed my eyes.
The smell of oil.
My father’s hands.
The floorboard.
The song.
“He hid something under the garage floor,” I said. “But the house was torn down years ago.”
Matthew shook his head.
“The house was torn down. The garage was not.”
I opened my eyes.
“What?”
“The property was bought by a shell company. It has sat untouched for eighteen years.”
Detective Chen stood.
“Who owns it?”
Matthew’s voice was quiet.
“Victor Raines.”
The room seemed to shrink.
Hayes looked at me.
“You don’t have to do this.”
But I thought about the message.
The photo of my apartment.
The people who knew my name now.
Running had kept me alive as a child.
But I was not a child anymore.
“I’m going,” I said.
That night, we entered the old garage under cover of a city inspection warrant.
The building was decayed, hidden behind weeds and chain-link fencing. The roof sagged. The windows were boarded. But the old workbench still stood against the back wall.
Exactly where I remembered it.
My hands shook as I walked toward it.
I knelt beside the cracked concrete floor.
Then I began to sing.
Softly.
“Blue moon over the water…”
The words came back slowly.
“Little star, don’t cry…”
My father had changed the lyrics every time.
But one line never changed.
Count three boards from the shadow line.
I looked toward the window.
Moonlight cut across the floor.
Three boards from its edge, there was a thin crack in the concrete.
Matthew brought over a crowbar.
“Let me.”
“No,” I said.
I took it from him.
It took ten minutes to pry up the old panel.
Underneath was a rusted metal box wrapped in plastic.
Inside, there was a leather ledger.
A small cassette tape.
And a sealed envelope with my name written in my father’s handwriting.
Before I could touch it, gunfire exploded through the garage window.
Glass shattered.
Hayes shoved me to the floor.
Matthew drew the knife from his ankle and moved toward the shadows.
Outside, tires screamed.
A voice shouted from the darkness.
“Get the ledger!”
May you like
And I realized Victor Raines—or whoever was left of him—had been waiting for us all along.
---